Monday, February 25, 2013
Does television cause ADHD?
Televison and most all technology receives a bad reputation especially when it come to toddlers and young children using it. Television has been thought of as something that is bad for children's eye sight and attention span. iPads and computers are generally thought of as bad for toddlers to use. Most technology has been thought of as bad for the brain and brain function, which causes some people to think that technology, television included, can lead to ADHD. Technology is an easy target for criticism because people of all ages use it for all different purposes.
Could television have an impact on children's health or developing ADHD? Lisa Guernsey's book Screen Time: How Electronic Media -from Baby Videos to Educational Software-Affects Your Young Child brings up an interesting point on ADHD. "ADHD experts are much more convinced that attention disorders might cause television use, instead of the other way around. Even at the tender ages of 1 and 3- the age of the children in Christakis's study- these kids may have been tough for their parents to manage. Perhaps naptimes were a struggle. Maybe these children were not content with a pile of toys and would instead start climbing the stairs, the furniture and the baby gates-behavior parents considered more dangerous than watching TV." Parent's with ADHD children have recieved a lot of criticism about their parenting strategies. Parents of ADHD children have been told that their child has ADHD because the child was exposed to too much televison. Reading this book has shown that this may not be the case, but that parents allowed their child to watch televison because they needed a break. ADHD is a genetic disorder, not the fault of a parent or their parental strategies.
Argument against toddlers using technology, like reading books on iPads, is that they are not developing fine motor skills used to handle a book and turn the pages. When toddlers use technology they are often viewed as having low attention spans, and being lost or bored with traditional forms of learning and literacy. The article Do They Really Think Differently? by Marc Prensky suggests that yes, toddlers and young children do think differently. Our world is technologically advanced and widely available to people of all ages. Because children have access to technology almost everywhere they go, they do develop a sense of boredom with traditional literacy and learning. They may be bored but do not have ADHD. They may just require more brain stimulus.
Televison, computers and iPads are not harmful to your toddler or young child. It is important to keep in mind that balance and moderation is the key to receiving benefits. Allowing children computer and television time is appropriate as long as you allow them time to socialize and learn and explore without the use of technology.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I thought the perspective you have offered in your blog is intresting. I had never really considered the following point, "ADHD experts are much more convinced that attention disorders might cause television use, instead of the other way around." What an interesting idea! As the mother of two young children, a three year old and an eight month old, I have felt guilty about using the tv as a "sitter" while I try to make dinner or get some cleaning in. Of course, they are not in front of the TV all of the time, and we also spend a lot of time outside, so I do try to monitor their amount of usage. My three year old also loves to play games on my Kindle and phone, and picks up on how to play the game and the objective of the game so quickly! I look forward to reading more of your blogs to see what other perspectives you offer!
ReplyDeleteI found it interesting to note that you mentioned that some parents use the TV as a "sitter" for their kids. I have seen this tactic especially when my children are visiting their grandparents; one of the first things they ask my kids is what would you like to watch on TV or go ahead and find something on TV to watch. My husband and I monitor are children's time with anything technology based. As you have mentioned a couple of times - balance it the best way to go.
ReplyDeleteLooking forward to reading more on the ADHD topic as it relates to TV usage.
Yes, as long as television is used in moderation, it is harmless. It does have an effect on the alpha, beta and gamma brainwaves which get modified while watching television, and can cause sleeping disorders and more if used in excess, like anything else. Frequent breaks are important, just like with other digital devices. Great topic!
ReplyDeleteIt seems that the cause and effect of technology and children is not a clear cut issue. I agree that we need to find balance. This is a real challenge. It's going to be interesting to follow your blog. Thanks!
ReplyDelete